I’m currently reading The Wise Man’s Fear, Patrick Rothfuss’ sequel to The Name of the Wind. I’m about halfway through it and I’m really enjoying it – I’ll write a review when I’m done – but first, a quick rant. (Avast, mateys! Mild spoilers abound!)
Denna, the main character’s love interest, is driving me crazy. She is mysterious and beautiful. And mysterious and beautiful. And – oh look, she picked up a hobby relevant to the main character and did a stupidly generous thing for Kvothe, the main character and has a moment of deep insecurity in the second book, in addition to continuing to be mysterious and beautiful. (A moment, mind you. Not a developed theme or anything. Just a completely predictable “beautiful-girl-who-seems-to-have-it-all-together-is-actually-vastly-insecure” moment.)
Arg! Seriously, Rothfuss? Seriously?! You have this intelligent, headstrong, complex daring main character who is having these fantastic moments of character development and all you can think of for a girl worthy of his love is – mysterious and beautiful? There’s not exactly a windfall of well-developed female characters in these (massive) novels, but, hell, any of the others would make a better love interest than Denna. I feel I could easily replace her with whatever stereotype springs to mind when I say “mysterious, beautiful” lady and it would not detract from either the story or the love plot at all.
I can’t even give her credit for street smarts because 1) extremely stupid moment of generosity mentioned above. Look, all I’m saying is if you’re constantly depending on others’ good will to support yourself, you often find yourself in straits, and you come into a huge windfall of money, don’t spend it all on a boy. And 2) she is being incredibly naive and gullible as it pertains to other mysterious people.
This is the only part of the book I sincerely dislike. But, oh, how much I dislike it! Please, people, if you’re going to make your books all about one character who’s amazing and super-intelligent and brave, ect., ect., can you take some time to write a love interest that seems realistically intriguing and engaging as a person? Beauty and mystery are no basis for a relationship.